❝

“I do not understand exactly why I prefer Haydn to my good friend who prefers Beethoven. But we both agree (as do all civilized human beings) that both Messrs. Haydn and Beethoven are numerous steps further along the evolutionary trail than Dimebag Abbott.”

–William E. Grim.

In 2004, Pantera and Damageplan guitarist, Darrell Lance Abbott was shot and murdered on stage by 25-year-old ex-marine, Nathan Gale. 

The metal world was left reeling in horror. 

Abbott – better known as “Dimebag Darrell” – was a beloved figure and an icon to aspiring guitarists.

And little did we metal fans know… 

There was more yet to come.

Six days after the shooting, an article appeared online, “Aesthetics of Hate: R.I.P. Dimebag Abbott, & good riddance”, penned by William E. Grim, contributing editor to the online conservative website, Iconoclast. 

The article was unsympathetic to Darrell’s demise. Grim believed that his death was of his own making. 

He described Darrell as “freakish in appearance, more simian than human”. 

According to Grim, the fans who showed up to mourn Darrell were “an assemblage of ignorant, semi-human barbarians who were filthy in attire and manner, intellectually incoherent and above all else, hideously ugly to the point of physical deformity.”

❝

“But one can see why the heavy metal fans so closely identified with Mr. Abbott. He was an ignorant, barbaric, untalented possessor of a guitar and large amplifier system.”

–William E. Grim.

Grim’s vitriol wasn’t a new phenomenon. It was simply the latest iteration of a half-century-old cycle of elitism…

The Aesthetes of Hate

The very label “Heavy Metal” began its life not as a badge of honor, but as a sneer from critics who found the music ponderous, mechanical, and – above all – unintelligent. 

To the early-70s press, this sound was merely “noise” for the “uncivilized” – and “Heavy Metal” was a derogatory term used to describe music that felt thick, slow, mechanised and stupid.

❝

“I am a conservative elitist. I want the very best. The very best form of government, the very best of civilizations, the very best educational system, the very best literature and art, the very best music, the very best way of life.”

–William E. Grim.
But unlike Grim, the best of the “elitists” eventually evolved. 

Legendary critic Lester Bangs famously trashed Black Sabbath’s eponymous debut, only to realize a year later that their "ugly" distortion was the only honest mirror for a world that had lost its polish. 

It took some time, but Bangs realized, eventually, that the “barbarians” were the ones telling the truth.

Grim, however, chose to stay in his ivory tower, clutching his Haydn records and calling us “simian”. 

And yet, he failed to understand the foundational law of this genre – in metal, being called “noisy” or “ugly” isn’t so much a slur… it’s part of the raw appeal.

In this sense, Machine Head completed a 50-year reclamation project. By taking the title of a hateful essay and turning it into an anthem, they demonstrated that being called “barbaric” is often just shorthand for being honest and real.

It makes sense then that “Aesthetics Of Hate” came to Robb Flynn, lead singer and guitarist of Machine Head, as:

“A neanderthal burst of anger.”

Taking the article’s title as inspiration, “Aesthetics Of Hate” rages against elitism and is a vitriolic defence of metal as an artform.

The song doesn’t pretend to be beautiful. 

It channels the “ugly”, raw energy of metal into the song. 

Meaning the song is intentionally discordant. 

It starts with an ominous intro. 

A brutal, downpicked thrash riff follows… but it’s a false start. 

A guitar pick scrapes the lower strings before harsh, double-stop bends welcome back the crushing thrash riff.

Throughout the verses, frantic, down-picked, Exodus-inspired riffs chase one another up and down the fretboard. 

Staccato power chords are used to emphasise Robb Flynn’s vocals in the third line of each verse: “You called us pathetic for our respect.”

And while the guitarists Robb Flynn and Phil Demmell remain in harmony throughout, they are rarely in sync. 

This “call and response” guitar duelling throughout the song raises the tension. Listeners feel on edge and – subconsciously – are waiting for those (rare) moments when the two guitars are playing the same notes, even if just for a moment.

This edginess leaks into the breakdown and solo. The song moves from classic thrash to a modern (at the time) metalcore-style breakdown. Each alternate-picked stream of open notes feels like a question. One which is never resolved by the rapid answering phrase.

The ensuing solo feels like a true tribute to the fallen icon. Trilling and pinch harmonics (a staple of Dimebag’s style) abound. As do whammy bar antics and ascending, alternate-picked licks.

This effort shows us that Grim’s article had pushed Machine Head to the point where they were:

Far Beyond Driven

The name of this bestselling Pantera album is woven into the lyrics: 

“He made us Driven/Such deep reverence/Far Beyond the rest.”

Far Beyond Driven was the first extreme metal album to debut at #1 on the Billboard 200. 

This reminded us that Dimebag wasn't just some "untalented possessor of a guitar", but a chart-topping, musical pioneer.

Just as Grim has penned "Aesthetics of Hate" to judge a subculture he didn't understand, Robb Flynn took that same title to defend that subculture.

❝

“It was highly amusing, and also terribly sad, to watch on television fans conducting a "vigil" for the slain Mr. Abbott outside of the Alrosa Villa. It was an assemblage of ignorant, semi-human barbarians who were filthy in attire and manner, intellectually incoherent and above all else, hideously ugly to the point of physical deformity. Here is a definite case in which the outer appearance of these "fans" accurately represented the hideousness of their souls. That the physical deformity of their ugliness was self-inflicted makes the spiritual tragedy of their misspent lives all the more tragic.”

–William E. Grim.
Grim’s article is challenging to find online.

While researching this newsletter, I could only find a reprint on metaldisciple[dot]com.

The Iconoclast website no longer exists. Iconoclast[dot]ca now leads (somewhat hilariously) to an interior design website, Icon Clast Homes. 

And yet, “Aesthetics Of Hate” has become a canonical metal song. Not only that – it was nominated for a Grammy (Best Metal Performance, 2008).

A truly iconic piece of art.

Because here’s the thing.

Real art is often ugly. 

Because real humans are often ugly.

And while elitists like Grim argue that art should be "civilized" like Haydn or Beethoven.

Machine Head argue that art should reflect the raw reality of the human condition.

The band embraced their ugly “unaesthetic” music style to create a lasting impression on the art scene. And on metal.

For those reasons, the song was prophetic:

❝

“But your hate was over all too soon
Because nothing is over
And nothing's through
Till we bury you”

–Machine Head

It’s time to consider William Grim and the publication at which he was a “contributing editor” very much buried.