Prefer to listen? Chuggers get every issue read aloud on the private podcast.

THE CHUG
The Green Manalishi
The news catches the jetlagged Rob Halford off guard.
Judas Priest’s label wants the band to record their first live album while they’re touring in Tokyo.
He’s been trying to keep himself awake all day to perform the show and – hopefully – sleep that night.
And now they want to record him live?
“Don't you come creepin' around”
Halford’s not happy with the performance. The guitars, bass and drums came out as expected in the recording, but Halford’s voice was shot.
It lacks the power and sound that makes Rob Halford… well, Rob Halford.
But he has a plan.
The band's producer, Tom Allom, has taken the live tapes to Startling Studios – the recording facility located on Ringo Starr’s Tittenhurst Park estate in Ascot, England – to mix the album.
Once inside the studio:
“I said to Tom Allom (producer) that I was going to sing the entire show, without taking any breaks […] That was a genuine front-to-end live performance”
Pretending he’s back in Japan in the living room of a Beatle’s mansion.
That didn’t stop some fans dubbing the resulting live album, Unleashed in the East (1979), as “Unleashed in the Studio”.
No matter. Unleashed quickly became the band’s bestselling album up to that point.
And while there were a number of standout songs from the live album, one of the most notable performances is a cover song: a cover of Fleetwood Mac’s “The Green Manalishi (With the Two Prong Crown)” – a song they’d previously released on the US version of their 1978 album, Killing Machine – re-titled Hell Bent for Leather in the US.
The late Les Binks, Priest’s drummer at the time, remembers that the suggestion to cover Fleetwood Mac came from Columbia Records:
“CBS suggested we record a version of Peter Green’s Fleetwood Mac’s “Green Manalishi” and as we all love Greenie we gave it the Judas Priest treatment and that was recorded at CBS studios”
The song has since become a setlist staple. To the point that many fans of Judas Priest aren’t even aware the song isn’t an original Judas Priest song.
A record label went looking for a song to sell more Judas Priest records.
And picked a song about money as the devil.
“Makin' me do things I don't wanna do”
Eight years earlier, Peter Green is fighting his way out of a dream about a green dog.
“It scared me because I knew the dog had been dead a long time”
In the dream he’s dead too. He’s fighting to get back into his own body.
The next day, in Richmond Park, he writes “The Green Manalishi (With the Two Prong Crown)”.
Most people wouldn’t normally consider Fleetwood Mac as a “heavy” band.
Neither would I.
But there’s something undeniably heavy about this song. Other metal musicians have noticed it too. Metallica’s Kirk Hammett had this to say about it:
“To me, that song is so incredibly heavy. High-gain amps, high-output pickups, none of that stuff existed. That song sounds so incredibly dark, and so incredibly heavy, and it is atmospheric and it gets straight to the darkest parts of one’s psyche. That’s what happened to me”
"The Green Manalishi” was released in 1970 – a time when heavy metal was still in its infancy.
It’s a dark and brooding song.
Open notes bleed over the chugging guitar lines. Towards the end of the song, Green howls like some deranged crossover between a wolf and a banshee.
Just three months earlier, Black Sabbath had released their eponymous debut. And there are comparisons to be found between the dark, Robert Johnson-inspired, heavy blues blueprint both bands were working from.
But while Black Sabbath’s evil verges on a schlocky horror movie depiction of Satan, Green is depicting money as the true evil in society.
Martin Celmins, Green’s biographer, explains it so:
“The Green Manalishi defies analysis really. In fact, the word derives from ‘greenbacks’, American slang for dollars. A song about money as the devil incarnate, in a way marks the start of Peter Green’s slow retreat from a crazy world to a place and time of his own”
The title of the song makes explicit the song’s meaning. “Greenbacks”, aka “dollars”, are depicted as a terrifying, brooding presence with a two-pronged, devilish crown.
The lyrics are genuinely weird and unsettling. The night falls and the Green Manalishi starts making the protagonist do things he doesn’t “wanna do”:
“Don't you come creepin' around
Makin' me do things I don't wanna do”
Yet despite its menace, there’s something pathetic about this evil figure.
“Can't believe that you need my love so bad”
It’s a persistent presence that keeps following our protagonist. And simply won’t leave him alone – “bustin’ in” on his dreams and driving him “mad”.
It reads like a man trying to break up with money. But the money refuses to leave.
“Can't believe that you need my love so bad”
The story behind the song is well documented. In December 1968, at the start of a touring cycle, the band tried LSD for the first time, courtesy of Owsley Stanley – who, according to the official website of his foundation, was “most widely known as the “Acid King” for his early role manufacturing the highest quality LSD to help fuel the psychedelic revolution of the 1960s”.
By early 1970, the band were already playing the new song live.
Then, in March, they played Munich.
There, they were met by delegates from the High-Fish Commune, a left-wing collective preaching free love and drugs. Mark Blake, writing for Classic Rock, notes that, for many, this was “a tipping point in his mental decline”:
“Back in England, he told the band that he wanted to give away all of his money. […] Ever sensitive, he had apparently been moved to tears by TV footage of the recent famine in Biafra. ‘I just wanted to make a contribution. They [the band] thought I wanted to give it all away, but I wanted them to do it as well’. Green wrote cheques for large sums to a number of charities; the rest of the group and their management were reluctant to do the same. But the guitarist’s messianic vision persisted”
Blake spots the irony:
“Perversely, a song about the evils of money was about to make its composer even more of it”
The song was engineered by Martin Birch, who would later produce heavy metal bands like Black Sabbath, Rainbow and Iron Maiden. Birch had some novel ideas for how to create the eerie, ethereal guitar sound:
“Martin Birch, who produced it, was similarly inspired by the material, engineering the intro guitar tone by placing speakers in an underground car park and miking it up for the natural reverb to swallow it, the ambience a proxy for the dream logic that inspired Green in the first place”
The band needs 27 takes to get it right. Green walks out exhausted.
“It took me at least two years to recover from that song”
Even so, he wasn’t fully satisfied. Decades later, he said it was nearly brilliant, but:
“‘Green Manalishi’ of ours was quite good, it was on the way to brilliant, but it should have been a little bit quieter…”
Mark Blake from Classic Rock links this rejection of success back to his LSD use:
“[…] just as rock music was becoming big business, Green turned his back on it all, tortured by guilt over the money he was making and with his thought processes damaged by hallucinogenic drugs”
Not everyone pins it on the acid.
In 2012, Jeremy Spencer told Classic Rock he thinks “there has been a bit too much blame put on it”.
“In the mid-70s, Green was diagnosed with schizophrenia”
By the time the single hit No.10 in the UK, he’d already left the band he founded.
“All my tryin' is up all your bringin' is down”
Eight years later, the song lands at CBS.
Mark Blake from Classic Rock believes Judas Priest’s cover is the “heavy metal song it always threatened to be”. Others don’t speak about the cover in the same favorable terms. In 1997, Hot Press’s Andy Darlington described it as a “ham-fisted heavy metal cover”.
The cover was orchestrated by CBS, Priest’s label, to sell more records.
A song about money as the devil. Recorded to make money.
The song loses much of its menace because of its sped-up tempo and studio polish (in both the studio and the live version.)
And unlike the original version, that “live” vocal wasn't cut in a concrete car park.
It was cut in Ringo Starr’s living room.
So while on the surface it might sound “heavier” (due to more modern distortion techniques in the studio), the Fleetwood Mac version – like Black Sabbath’s “Black Sabbath” – genuinely makes listeners’ skin crawl.
But there was another band who covered the song. And who arguably had a better sense of the assignment.
The Melvins.
“Just takin’ my love then slippin’ away”
A creepier, and lesser known, cover of “The Green Manalishi (With The Two Prong Crown)” was recorded by the Melvins and released on their 1999 album, The Maggot.
The Melvins had already taken the major-label money.
They’d been signed by Atlantic during the grunge gold rush.
But after three albums, they were dropped.
So The Maggot came out on Ipecac, an independent label barely six weeks old.
A song about money as the devil. Recorded by a band the money had already spat out.
The Melvins capture something that's missing from the gleaming, polished version Judas Priest made.
The Melvins understood that “heavier” doesn't always equate with “faster”. A truly heavy song crushes, lumbers, pounds.
Slowed down, the Melvins’ cover feels more authentic. Darker. More aligned with the source material:
“The Melvins covered it, too, lacing it with a knowing venom as they stretched it out to nearly seven minutes, performed lower and slower but more in the spirit of the original”
Green wanted his version quieter. The Melvins made it slower, lower and heavier instead.
And where Green howled at the end, they left a squall of noise.
Yet The Melvins’ Buzz Osborne still claims that Judas Priest’s Unleashed in the East is “the greatest metal record of all time”:
“Judas Priest has always been one of my favorite bands […] I think Unleashed in the East is the greatest metal record of all time.”
And in a Revolver interview from 2020, he told Halford that Priest did “such a great version” of the “Green Manalishi”:
“Also "Green Manalishi," which, I was wondering, did you ever see Peter Green play? You guys must have been fans of that stuff ... You did such a great version of that, as well”
Halford never got to meet Green:
“We never had the chance to meet up, the stars were never aligned”
For Halford, the point of a cover is to give a song a “second identity”.
Priest did.
The Melvins gave it back its first.
Horns up 🤘
Shane
Editor-in-chief
The Chug Media
Bring fellow metalheads into the pit. Refer 3 friends and your next month of Chugger is on me. The more you refer, the more free months you stack up.




