"Pull Me Under"

THE CHUG

"Pull Me Under"

00:00
00:00

Introducing: a new feature for paid subscribers, a private podcast exclusive to paid members – now you can listen to me read the issue to you. Best for when you’re driving, walking or simply doing things around the house.

FYI: I’ve just set this up and I’m still ironing out some kinks. Let me know if you have any problems accessing it.

Almost two years and 200 singers later, Dream Theater had finally found their man. 

A Canadian. Kevin James LaBrie. 

Or just James LaBrie. 

It was simpler to drop his first name. Kevin Moore, the band’s keyboardist and sometimes-lyricist, was already established within the band. What’s more, there were already two “Johns” in the band – John Petrucci and John Myung. 

Two Johns and two Kevins would have been too much. 

Act I: “Lost in the sky”

By this time, in 1991, Dream Theater had spent two years in a strange limbo. No frontman to lead the band. And trapped in a record deal with Mechanic Records.

❝

“We were working day jobs every day, going to practice every night, looking for a new singer, looking for a new record deal,” says Portnoy. “It was a very hard time. I’m shocked we made it through. But we persevered and we finally got the payoff”

Mike Portnoy, Prog, article republished online on 4 August 2026

While the band seems to have blamed Mechanic Records for their “stuckness”, the record label’s manager, Steve Sinclair remembers it differently:

❝

“It seems that the band have unfairly blamed Mechanic for hanging them up but I can assure you that that is not the case. If I had thought that we were delaying their development at all I would have released them immediately”

Steve Sinclair, qtd. in Lifting Shadows

Sinclair’s perspective – at least as he told it later – was that keeping the band signed to Mechanic while they didn’t have a singer wouldn’t hurt their progress. Eventually Atco Records bought them out based on the strength of a demo with four instrumental tracks. 

Derek Shulman, head of Atco, who had signed Bon Jovi and Cinderella (and who had once sung in prog band Gentle Giant), later described it as an “odd” thing to sign a band without a frontman:

❝

“So it was odd to be talking about signing an artist based on four songs without any vocals”

Derek Shulman, qtd. in Lifting Shadows

But this deal didn't guarantee success for Dream Theater. Shulman only offered the band a “development deal”... Atco would pay for recordings, and decide afterwards whether the band was worth keeping.

It would be up to Dream Theater to earn their keep. 

Act II: “If not today nor yet tomorrow then some other day”

To do this, they would need a singer. This meant doubling down on their efforts.

The band had already spent the best part of two years auditioning singers – around two hundred of them, one of them calling himself “The Crazy Viking” – before a tape arrived from the singer of a Canadian band called Winter Rose. 

They were so taken by James LaBrie’s voice that they immediately called him in to audition. He was quickly offered the job.

In 1991 they went into BearTracks Recording Studio with LaBrie in tow and a new producer picked by the label, David Prater. They cut three songs properly, with James singing. “Metropolis.” “Take The Time.” “To Live Forever.”

The “developmental” deal involved a lot of back and forth between Dream Theater and Atco. This is documented on the tracklisting from the Images and Words Demos (1989-1991), first released in 2005. On this appears “Oliver’s Twist”, an instrumental version of what would become “Pull Me Under” – although running even longer than the studio track at 9 minutes, 42 seconds long.

YouTube Thumbnail for Dream Theater - Images and Words Demos (Full Album)

Click above to listen to Dream Theater - Images and Words Demos (Full Album)

Act III: “Orders fly and I fall again”

Keyboardist Kevin Moore is on the verge of punching the band’s new producer, David Prater…

By now, the show is back on the road. Dream Theater have a new singer and a new record deal. 

If only they could get along with Prater.

Despite having a wishlist of producers they wanted to work with, they were “strong-armed” (the band’s words) into settling for Prater who would describe the band as “typical, self-absorbed Long Island rock musicians” in Dream Theater’s biography, Lifting Shadows (2007).

The producer has just wiped Moore’s keyboard parts, claiming the keyboardist played them “incorrectly”. 

The band is livid. It’s the beginning of a grudge that would last for many years. Drummer Mike Portnoy remembers:

❝

“Making Images And Words with David Prater was a complete fucking nightmare […] Dealing with this asshole was torturous. We were incredibly thrilled to finally have a singer and record deal and be back in the studio again, but little did we know that another rollercoaster ride was ahead of us”

Mike Portnoy, Metal Hammer 158, republished on 11 July 2024

Wiping Moore’s recordings would have been akin to blasphemy to Dream Theater, who – from the beginning of their career – demanded full creative control over the working process and who were becoming increasingly frustrated by exterior forces meddling in their work (including Atco Records, their new record label, who were working behind the band’s back to replace their carefully-chosen singer, LaBrie, with singer Robert Mason.)

But despite everything, Mike Portnoy still has some grudging respect for Prater’s work:

❝

“[…] somebody had to provide that push towards the mainstream or it might’ve disappeared into oblivion,” he admits. “As much as David Prater is one of my least favourite human beings on the planet, I have to give him credit for that”

Mike Portnoy, Metal Hammer 158, republished on 11 July 2024

That mainstream push was important for this genre-melding “prog metal” band labelled by the music media as “Rush meets Metallica”. 

Indeed, they essentially invented – and defined – this new subgenre of metal in the late 80s and early 90s (along with Watchtower, Fates Warning and Queensrÿche), paving the way for other mind-expanding, prog metal bands like Mastodon, Between The Buried and Me, The Dillinger Escape Plan… and countless others.

Act IV: “Pull Me Under”

YouTube Thumbnail for Dream Theater's "Pull Me Under"

Click above to listen to Dream Theater’s “Pull Me Under”

Every critic mentions the song’s connection to William Shakespeare’s Hamlet. But few have delved into it deeply.

For those unfamiliar, the core idea of Shakespeare’s play is as follows:

Hamlet, the Prince of Denmark, is trapped by his own inability to take action. His father, the king, has been killed by his uncle, Claudius. Having immediately married his brother’s wife – Hamlet’s mother, the queen – Claudius takes his dead brother’s place as king. 

This sense of “stuckness” seems to have been shared by Dream Theater at the time of writing.

Since releasing their first album When Dream and Day Unite (1989), Dream Theater had been stuck – locked into contract with their old record label, Mechanic, and stuck without a singer (despite the number of auditions creeping into the hundreds.) 

The lyrics directly address the relentless circularity of their days:

❝

“This world is spinning around me
This world is spinning without me and
Every day sends future to past
Every breath leaves me one less to my last”

Dream Theater, “Pull Me Under”

The world is both spinning “around me” and “without me”. 

To move forward, Hamlet needs to kill his uncle, the new king, and reclaim his right to the throne. But until he enacts revenge he remains stuck, unable to move forward or backward.

The band is stuck because of external factors blocking them. 

But the result is the same for both. 

The world spins. Future quickly becomes past. Every day that passes without action, brings you closer to death. But no closer to your goals.

The line:

❝

“Oh that this too
Too solid flesh
Would melt”

William Shakespeare, Hamlet (and Dream Theater, “Pull Me Under”)

…is quoted verbatim at the end of the song. 

This quote comes from Act I, Scene II, where Hamlet wishes that “the Everlasting had not fix'd His canon ’gainst self-slaughter”. In other words, the only thing stopping Hamlet from taking his own life is the thought of a worse fate on the other side. His flesh feels too solid, too physical. 

This desire to melt and stop existing is reflected in both the chorus and title of the song, “Pull Me Under”, and evokes Hamlet’s most famous soliloquy:

❝

“To be, or not to be, that is the question:
Whether 'tis nobler in the mind to suffer
The slings and arrows of outrageous fortune,
Or to take arms against a sea of troubles
And by opposing end them”

William Shakespeare, Hamlet

In “Pull Me Under”, these same arrows “fly”, while the sea of troubles rise and fall again:

❝

“Arrows fly
Seas increase and then fall again”

Dream Theater, “Pull Me Under”

The challenge for Hamlet – and for Dream Theater – is to oppose these challenges, and by doing so, putting an end to the long period of inactivity and doubt.  

Act V: “Living my life too much in the sun”

But Prater’s gamble with the mainstream elements paid off.

Despite grunge’s explosion – and the assertions that metal was, once again, dead – Dream Theater’s album Images and Words was a hit. Well, as much of a hit as technical, prog metal album can expect to be, reaching #61 on the US Billboard 200 chart.

“Pull Me Under” became the album’s lead single and gave the band its first – and only – top 10 Mainstream Rock hit.

The 8-minute song was shortened to less than 5 minutes for the music video:

YouTube Thumbnail for "Pull Me Under" Music Video

Click above to listen to the shortened version of Dream Theater’s “Pull Me Under”

The band were allegedly very unhappy with the song being cut down and the music video’s convoluted plot (which has nothing to do with Hamlet or the source material.)

However, the song received a lot of airtime on MTV and radio and its success guaranteed a future for Dream Theater – and became a beacon of hope for technical metal in the era of stripped-down grunge.

Right after the direct quote from Hamlet – “Oh that this too too solid flesh would melt” – the song cuts sharply. 

It’s an abrupt ending, but perhaps less so in the context of a suicidal son mourning his father’s murder and betrayal.

Only two years later, keyboardist and writer of the lyrics for “Pull Me Under”, Kevin Moore, would depart from the band.

How much of this was due to his feelings of being “stuck” during the Images and Words recording sessions, we can only surmise. 

But his experience with David Prater deleting his tapes and forcing him to re-do the keyboard tracks cannot have helped the cause. 

❝

“All that I feel is honor and spite
All I can do is to set it right”

Dream Theater, “Pull Me Under”

After spending years pursuing a solo career in music, Moore went back to medical school in the early 2010s according to Fates Warning vocalist Ray Alder.

A songwriter inspired by Hamlet’s desire to be “pulled under” now provides “comprehensive psychiatric care for adults dealing with a wide range of mental health issues, including mood disorders, anxiety disorders, and psychotic disorders”.

Pretty f*cking metal, if you ask me.

Horns up 🤘

Shane 
Editor-in-chief
The Chug Media