Prefer to listen? Chuggers get every issue read aloud on the private podcast.

THE CHUG
"No More Mr. Nice Guy"
Alice Cooper is many things.
Preacher’s son. Alleged chicken killer. Executionee. Born-again Christian. Godfather of “shock rock”.
But you know what he’s not?
A nice guy.
Well, not since 1973.
“I used to be such a sweet, sweet thing”
The first time I heard Alice Cooper as a young teenager was “Poison”. So I’ve always associated him with large, poppy, late-80s stadium rock.
It wouldn’t be long before I’d also discover his other greatest hits – “School’s Out”, “I’m Eighteen”, and, of course, “No More Mr. Nice Guy”.
I was enthralled by the stage antics. The electrocutions. The make-up. The bizarre name. And just the general transgression and performativity.
Around the same time I started listening to heavy music, Alice Cooper was also invading Irish airwaves. His radio show, Nights with Alice Cooper, was broadcast every Saturday night on Ireland’s Today FM between 2006-2007 – helping to shape my taste in heavier music during my formative years.
“And I'm feelin’ real shot down”
Alice Cooper’s guitarist, Michael Bruce, first wrote “No More Mr. Nice Guy” as a song about heartbreak:
“Bruce had originally written it from the perspective of a guy whose girlfriend uses him for a doormat”
According to Bob Ezrin, one of Alice Cooper’s most frequent producers, Michael Bruce was “the riffmeister of the band, and a really good pop writer” (Ibid.) He was frustrated that Cooper didn’t keep the original as it was:
“Why don’t you do it the way it is?”
And that’s all it really was at first. A poppy song about love gone wrong. And for some years, the band struggled to find an album to place the song. Bruce himself admits that the song was simply “too pop” for earlier Alice Cooper records:
“I had written it after Love It to Death and before Killer [both in 1971], and then School’s Out [1972…] I kept pushing and bringing the song up, but it didn't fit. It was too pop”
More pop than rock. And heavily influenced by The Who’s song, “Substitute”.
“The song was actually a pop song […] It was pretty much based after ’Substitute.’ … it was maybe the most pop record we ever did. It was kind of an in-joke for us”
The “Who”-style riff and “girl/boy” relationship lyrics didn’t really match Alice Cooper’s shock-rock stage persona who had, since the very early 70s, become famous for beheading “babies” (toy dolls) and executing himself on stage, night-after-night.
So he took Michael Bruce’s music and rewrote the lyrics over them – lyrics that seemed to perfectly describe the “origin story” of his stage persona, Alice Cooper.
“No More Mr. Nice Guy”
Vincent Damon Furnier was born a preacher’s son in Detroit on February 4, 1948.
By 1973, the year Billion Dollar Babies was released, he had firmly established himself as the shock-rock icon, “Alice Cooper”.
The song itself seems to detail the transformation:
“I used to be such a sweet, sweet thing
’Til they got a hold of me”
The unidentified third party – “they” – gives the song a hint of menace from the outset. The figure seems almost Christ-like: not only is he holding doors for “little old ladies”, he’s helping the blind see.
He’s “got no friends” because they “can’t be seen” with him. Feeling progressively more ostracised, he vows to himself:
“No more Mr. Nice Guy”
The most clearly personal – perhaps openly autobiographical – lines of the song come in the final verses.
The preacher’s son, Cooper, whose father has to “hide” goes to church “incognito”:
“When everybody rose
The Reverend Smith, he, he recognized me
And punched me in the nose”
It’s telling that the Reverend is the one telling Cooper that he’s “sick” and “obscene”.
“That was autobiographical […] Everybody at that point didn’t know whether to hate us or love us. But I was definitely, with the general public, the worst person ever. I was the Antichrist, I was everything. And I said, ‘Okay, that does it. Gloves are off – no more Mr. Nice Guy. Now we’re gonna get rough’”
But Alice changed the lyrics and made it about himself, or, at least, his persona.
“With Cooper's rewrite, ‘No More Mr. Nice Guy’ became an anthem to nonconformity while providing a back story to Alice's outlandish behavior”
“And I’m feeling mean”
While I’m not trying to make the argument that “No More Mr. Nice Guy” is a metal song, the imagery and lyrics definitely made a huge impact on the metal world. Perhaps “proto-metal” would be an accurate descriptor (if we’re trying to pin it into some subgenre, as we metal fans are often wont to do.)
But the bands that came next were watching.
KISS borrowed heavily from Alice Cooper. When Paul Stanley picked out the songs that made the Alice character, “No More Mr. Nice Guy” was one of the two he named:
“Alice was the personification of rock and roll danger”
So it can’t have been too surprising when – 16 years after the song’s release – that Megadeth released a cover of the song, shaping it into the metal song it had always threatened to be.
Their cover came out in 1989, recorded for Wes Craven’s slasher film Shocker. It reached No.13 in the UK.
By this time Megadeth were firmly established in the raging thrash metal scene of the 80s. But this wasn’t a band covering a stranger. Megadeth had toured as Alice’s support act on his Constrictor tour, and Alice, sober by then, had taken Dave Mustaine under his wing:
“He’s actually my godfather”
The original “nasty” guy of rock & roll became the man who helped metal’s angriest frontman get clean.
“They say he’s sick, he’s obscene”
The strangest cover of the song was still to come.
In January 1997, Pat Boone released In a Metal Mood: No More Mr. Nice Guy.
Boone, a gospel-singing American crooner, released an album filled with big-band versions of Led Zeppelin, Deep Purple, Ozzy Osbourne, Metallica and more. Ritchie Blackmore and Ronnie James Dio even guested.
To sell it, legendary television producer and host Dick Clark had an idea for that month’s American Music Awards:
“Dick’s idea was that Alice and I should swap images”
But Alice ended up coming as… himself, Alice. He was shocked when Boone actually kept his part of the deal, walking out in a leather vest, a studded dog collar and stick-on tattoos:
“This new look was drastically different than his usual clean-cut appearance. Fans were pretty much shocked, and some even took serious offense”
According to Billboard, Boone “took pleasure in shocking the king of shock rock”. Unfortunately, his audience didn’t.
Trinity Broadcasting Network, America’s biggest Christian TV channel, pulled his show Gospel America off the air and asked viewers to pray for him.
A churchgoer, cast out for looking like a sinner. Suddenly Boone was no longer “Mr. Nice Guy” in the eyes of Christian America.
Weeks later, Boone went back on Trinity Broadcasting Network for what was effectively a trial. His pastor defended him, viewers voted by phone, and his show came back. And who had told him to see the whole thing as God’s work? The original “Nice Guy” himself:
“God’s in this. I feel it. You feel it”
In 2024, Alice re-recorded the song.
But this time, for a children’s charity album, with “kid-friendly” lyrics:
“I went to church and took my seat
The reverend testified
He smiled at me and he recognized
How I changed my life”
The song’s new title?
“Now I’m Mr. Nice Guy.”
Horns up 🤘
Shane
Editor-in-chief
The Chug Media
Want to see how this issue was built? Explore all the resources I checked (and more!) in this week’s “Go Further”… Exclusively for Chuggers.
Bring fellow metalheads into the pit. Refer 3 friends and your next month of Chugger is on me. The more you refer, the more free months you stack up.





