October 21, 2005.
The sounds of the crowd still ring in her ears as Tarja Turunen, Nightwish frontwoman, greets her bandmates after the show.
They pull her into a hug.
Normally they only do this before a show, but she’s too elated to question why.
Nightwish had just played the most important show of their career at Hartwall Arena in Helsinki, Finland.
The show had been filmed, and would later be repackaged into the End of an Era CD/DVD combo the following year.
As the band separates from one another, Tarja’s handed a letter. She’s told not to open it until the following day. But of course she does.
And her world suddenly veers off its axis.
“Dear Tarja,
It’s time to choose whether the story of Nightwish ends here or whether it will continue for an undetermined period of time. We’ve been working with this creation for 9 years and we are not ready to give up yet. Nightwish is a way of life, something to live for, and we’re certain we can’t let it go.
Equally certain is the fact that we cannot go on with you.
[…]”
The next day the same letter is published in full to the front page of the band’s website.
Tarja is in shock. So are the fans.
She sees her face plastered over all the tabloids in Finland. It will stay there for the next three weeks.
The situation reaches such a height that even Finnish Prime Minister Matti Vanhanen is called to comment on the situation.
Out of desperation, she flies to Buenos Aires, Argentina with her husband. But even still she can’t escape the public furore.
“It was following me every day for the next couple of weeks, and the TV cameras were outside my door in Buenos Aires. I couldn’t even get outside of my apartment”
From here, she pens her own public response to Nightwish which she then publishes on her website.
“This is a moment of grief and pain and I find it very hard to speak
[...]”
In the late-90s, Nightwish was an anomaly in the metal world.
First, because Metal was still very much a male-dominated genre.
And second, because it was still somewhat unusual to blend orchestral elements into the mix at the time.
Although he initially envisaged Nightwish as a soft, acoustic, atmospheric project with heavy folk and ambient elements, the band’s primary founder and visionary Tuomas Holopainen changed direction after the band’s first demo as a three-piece (Holopainen, Tarja and guitarist Erno Vuorinen) – only introducing metal elements later on the band’s debut release, Angels Fall First (1997).
Holopainen has named Therion, My Dying Bride and Tiamat among what he was listening to at the time: bands pulling orchestral and gothic elements into extreme metal, before anyone ever labelled these efforts “symphonic”.
He was also listening to the small number of existing female-fronted metal bands:
“It was clear that it had to have a female singer, because at the time, The 3rd and the Mortal, Theatre of Tragedy from Norway, and The Gathering from Holland were a big thing to me.”
What would become known by the media as “symphonic metal” – orchestral ambition built around a soprano lead – arrives in 1997, independently… twice. The year Nightwish and Within Temptation both released their debuts.
Although the two albums have less in common than assumed, both bands boasted female singers with huge, operatic voices, “heavy” instrumentation, and a somewhat “gothic” sensibility – although the members of Nightwish have long resisted being confined to the gothic metal category:
“I don’t think Nightwish ever considered themselves to be a gothic band”
And with more metal bands than ever boasting female singers and musicians – think Epica, Xandria, Spiritbox, Jinjer, Crypta, In This Moment, Myrkur and Visions of Atlantis… – their influence has never been more obvious:
“Sharon [from Within Temptation] and Tarja were soon upheld as inspirations for a subsequent wave of symphonically inclined artists that included Epica, Leaves’ Eyes and Delain, dispelling the notion of metal as a boys’ club.”
“We’re sure this is an equally big relief to you as it is for us. We have all been feeling bad long enough
[...]”
Early 2004.
Nightwish are coming to the end of the Once recording sessions.
Tuomas Holopainen is tired. The band has spent almost a quarter of a million making their new record – the most money ever spent on a Finnish record to that date.
They’ve already used four studios to record the album: three in Finland (Tempputupa in Kitee, Finnvox in Helsinki and E-Major in Kerava) as well as Phoenix Sound studio in the UK.
He listens back to “Nemo” which is about to be released as the album’s lead single.
The final version of the song is about two minutes shorter than the original he’d written, having been convinced by recording engineer Tero Kinnunen to cut the “stupid” sections and slow the tempo down by “about 10bpm” (Tuomas Holopainen, qtd. in Metal Hammer.)
The song features orchestration from the London Session Orchestra, arranged by Pip Williams. Holopainen himself admitted that:
“It was really, really difficult to get [“Nemo”] to work. We worked with the arrangement for months, just to get the lyrics and melodies completely right. I don’t know why. It was originally two minutes longer and the music was faster”
The song is very raw and reflective, from the perspective of someone who feels insufficient – like a terrible person who ruins everything.
According to Holopainen,
“[… “Nemo”] was a page out of my diary, and I needed to get those emotions out. I felt so alone”
The lyrics explore the feelings of being lost without a “compass” or “honest heart”, while also longing for the past. The narrator desperately longs for a sense of identity, which appears linked to a past love:
“This is me forever
One of the lost ones
The one without a name”
“Nemo”, in Latin, literally translates to “no name”. (Holopainen has rejected any claims that the title has any reference to Jules Verne’s Captain Nemo or Finding Nemo.)
The narrator is lucid and self-aware of their plight. The act of writing is – of course – an exploration of the self:
“These lines, the last endeavor
To find the missing lifeline”
But even this creative act does not bring the narrator the relief they’re searching for. And so they plead for “soothing rain” to fall on their “loving heart” to help them “dream again”:
“For hope, I'd give my everything”
By the end of the song, the narrator has accepted their fate as a nameless entity:
“Nemo, my name forevermore”
They have not been “touched” with the love they were seeking and so their true name was never revealed. And with this acceptance, the narrator further depersonalizes themself by shifting from the first-person singular (“I”) to the third-person singular (“Nemo”):
“Nemo sailing home
Nemo letting go”
Their quest to find their name has been a failure and their “loving heart” remains “lost in the dark”. The narrator sets sail to return home, knowing that they will never be “full” or “complete”.
“While there would have been so many different possibilities and ways to express what they wanted to tell me with the letter, I remain unable to understand the way they chose to handle this. I am sorry that the guys got me so wrong. I don’t recognize myself at all from the way they described me.
[...]”
"Nemo" was released in April 2004, reaching #1 in Finland and Hungary (and hitting the top ten in four additional countries.)
The song ensured the massive global success of the Once album… and of Nightwish itself.
It did not, however, ensure the longevity of the band’s lineup.
Despite everything, both Tarja and Nightwish have gone on to achieve greater things.
Tarja launched her successful solo career. And Nightwish – after some teething issues with Tarja’s replacement, Anette Olzon – have gone from strength-to-strength with current lead singer, Floor Jansen.
But some things are less easily patched. Both letters still exist online, a quick search away, exactly as they were posted.
In a 2022 interview, Holopainen admitted that the situation “should have been dealt with so much better”. According to the Nightwish mastermind:
“Even though the wounds are still there on both sides, things are better”
Yet, speaking to Metal Hammer as recently as August 2026, Tarja still describes the band’s letter as a calculated attempt to “destroy [her] publicly” and admitted she “probably should’ve put them through hell” legally… but ultimately chose to “move on and leave”.
In recent years Tarja reconciled with former Nightwish bassist Marco Hietala after he apologized to her and her husband.
Since then, they have toured and recorded together:
“It was a ‘wow’ moment for me; he’s absolutely not the same person. We talk a lot about the past, and we call each other. He calls me when he needs advice; it’s a completely different scenario. He is the only person from my time in Nightwish I could work with again”
And to this day, “Nemo” still features in live setlists… for both Nightwish and Tarja.
“For hope, I’d give my everything”
🤘 Horns up 🤘
Shane
Editor-in-Chief
The Chug Media


