April 22, 1986. The Rainbow Music Hall in Denver Colorado. 

The crowd goes wild as Anthrax play through their set. Attendees clamber onto the stage just to dive straight back off it into the crowd. 

But one kid keeps stomping on lead guitarist Danny Spitz’ guitar pedals.

The band’s guitar tech, Artie Ring, jumps on stage and starts grappling with the kid. Within moments they fall and get sucked into the crowd.

From here accounts vary. Some tell of Artie being hospitalized. Others recall him dragging himself back onto the stage, clutching his back in pain. 

The version the band themselves recall goes like this.

They don’t see Artie again for hours. Turns out he has been hospitalized. When he returns, nursing his bruises, he tells them:

❝

“Oh man, I got caught in a mosh”

Scott Ian and Charlie Benante, “ANTHRAX 40 - EPISODE 7 - AMONG THE LIVING”, YouTube

Despite Artie’s obvious pain, the band find themselves laughing at Artie’s turn of phrase. And the phrase became the title of a song from Among the Living:

“Caught in a Mosh”

The title of the song is one of the first reported uses of the word “mosh” in metal.

Thumbnail for “Caught in a Mosh”

Click above to listen to “Caught in a Mosh”

“Moshing” and “mosh pits” had existed in the hardcore punk scene since the late-70s. The idea of “slam-dancing” appeared first in California, before later spreading to New York and other US cities in the early-80s. 

According to Tom Phelan at Far Out Magazine, the “term ‘mosh’ is half-credited to DC legends Bad Brains”:

❝

“Around 1980, singer HR ended their ‘Banned in DC’ blast with “mash it-mash down Babylon!” causing the crowd to slam dance like crazy. Possibly a nod to Leroy King’s 1977 King Tubby release, HR’s patois delivery was misinterpreted as ‘mosh’, and the name stuck”

Tom Phelan, Far Out Magazine, 23 January 2026

Anthrax were highly attuned to the hardcore and punk scenes in New York. 

Scott Ian and Charlie Benante had – two years previously – released the album Speak English or Die under the name Stormtroopers of Death (S.O.D.) right after the release of Anthrax’s second album, Spreading the Disease (1985).

Thumbnail og S.O.D.’s debut album, Speak English or Die.

Click above to listen to S.O.D.’s debut album. Maybe some day I’ll do a full dive into an S.O.D. 

Speak English or Die was one of the first crossover thrash albums to wear its hardcore influences so blatantly on its sleeves. 

The album even featured a song called “Milano Mosh”. 

So while the term “mosh” wasn’t invented by Anthrax, its members played a huge role in popularising the term and transporting it from the hardcore scene to the metal masses.

“I ain't gonna live my life this way”

Unlike the supposedly-diminutive Artie Ring, a lot of metalheads are happy to be caught in a mosh.

But the song’s meaning is slightly more nuanced than its title suggests. While inspired by their guitar tech’s unfortunate experience in Denver, the song delves into:

❝

“[…]that idea of being stuck in a place that you don’t wanna be in. Whether it’s your job, or a relationship… [unintelligible] each version of that song is about being stuck somewhere you don’t wanna be”

Scott Ian, “ANTHRAX 40 - EPISODE 7 - AMONG THE LIVING”, YouTube

This metaphor is expanded further in the song’s lyrics:

❝

“Shut up, shut up, I don't wanna hear your mouth
Your mother made a monster
Now get the hell out of my house”

Anthrax, “Caught in a Mosh”

On Among the Living, Anthrax weren’t frightened to write lyrics with their tongue firmly planted in cheek. Not to the same extent as the more provocative S.O.D., but they were very aware of how serious (or not) they were trying to be:

❝

“You're always in the way, like a beast on my back
Were you dropped as a baby 'cause brains you lack?”

Anthrax, “Caught in a Mosh”

Throughout the record, the band’s lyrical influences vary from adaptations of 2000 AD’s Judge Dredd comic books, Stephen King’s novella “Apt Pupil” and King’s novel The Stand. 

The “Whole Lotta Rosie” comparisons with “Caught in a Mosh” are justified. The main riff and chorus is built around notes pivoting off an open string – in this case the guitar’s low E string. The effect is a riff that seems to “bounce” and build tension from the outset of the song.

The gang vocals in the chorus are where the hardcore influence is most clear:

❝

“Can't stand it for another day
(I ain't gonna live my life this way)”

Anthrax, “Caught in a Mosh”

The gang vocals are also evocative of AC/DC’s punky rock & roll sound. 

Looking back, Scott Ian still considers it the quintessential Anthrax song for first-time listeners:

❝

“It’s like a greatest hits in one song. It’s got so many different aspects. It’s got hardcore, it’s got rock, it’s got metal. That main riff is like an AC/DC riff, but then you’ve got a hardcore breakdown in the middle, you’ve got the down-picking verses. It’s fast, it’s mid-tempo, it’s slow. It’s got everything”

Scott Ian, Revolver, October 6, 2022

The song’s music video hints at what’s to come. Scott Ian wears a Public Enemy t-shirt – 4 years before they’d collaborate together on “Bring the Noise”.

And indeed, it was during the ensuing Among The Living tour that Chuck D spotted the photo of Scott Ian sporting a Public Enemy t-shirt in Melody Maker at the Monsters of Rock festival at Donington Park. 

“Suffer for your words”

Five months after Artie Ring was sucked into a moshpit, Anthrax find themselves stuck somewhere they really never wanted to be.

They’re supporting Metallica in Europe on their Damage, Inc. Tour.

But – as most people know – that tour didn’t go as planned.

On 27 September, Metallica bassist Cliff Burton is thrown from his bunk bed and crushed by the band’s bus in Sweden.

Charlie Benante and Frank Bello spend the night walking around the block with James Hetfield hundreds of times. Or what feels like it.

Lars Ulrich has already gone back to his father’s house in Denmark.

Scott Ian sits with Kirk Hammett apart from the others. 

They don’t get up. They just stay there all night.

Caught in a mosh.

“Shut up, shut up, I don't wanna hear your mouth”

Another month passes. 

Anthrax are recording their third album in Quadradial Studios, Miami.

They’ve got six weeks to get the record done. And been given a bigger budget than they've ever had.

They track most of the record live in the studio. They hired Eddie Kramer to be the producer, looking for the “live” sound he was famous for capturing in the 70s for bands like KISS, Jimi Hendrix and Led Zeppelin. 

Anthrax weren’t pleased with what he played back to them:

❝

“He'd tried to make us sound like fucking Def Leppard”

Scott Ian, Metal Hammer, 22 March 2021

Eventually, a shouting match erupted between Anthrax and Kramer:

❝

“We came down hard on him. Every time he’d play us a mix, and we’d hear the slightest reverb on the drums, it would be: ‘No, we want the drums to sound dry, dry, dry. Throw the effects pedals into the ocean’”

Scott Ian, Ibid

Kramer was imitating the big, overproduced sounds favoured by younger, more “modern” producers like “Mutt” Lange on albums like Def Leppard’s Pyromania (1983). 

In 1979, Atlantic took AC/DC off Eddie Kramer and handed them to Mutt Lange. Lange made Highway to Hell. Then Back in Black. Then Pyromania.

But Anthrax were looking for the old live sounds of bands like “AC/DC” before they worked with Lange on Highway to Hell. The direct comparison to “Whole Lotta Rosie” makes this clear (the song was first released on AC/DC’s Let There Be Rock in 1977.) 

Instead of giving Anthrax the sound they were looking for (and the sound he was famous for producing), Kramer was trying to achieve the sound of his younger contemporaries.

The band turned their anger at Kramer into fuel:

❝

“No, in fact if anything it helped. We got so angry with him that all of us were fired up, and I think you can hear it on the record. There’s an edge which came from these disagreements. If anything, we speeded up the songs because of these confrontations, and got more extreme.”

Scott Ian, Ibid

Still, it can’t have been easy creating an album under such conditions. It’s not clear if the lyrics were fully written before the recording sessions, but with so much in-fighting between the band and producer, they could easily have been directed at Kramer:

❝

“Don't tell me how to do my job
There's the door, your name's on the knob”

Anthrax, “Caught in a Mosh”

Once again, Anthrax found itself caught in a mosh.

Among the Living was released on 22 March 1987. Dedicated to the late Cliff Burton.

Scott Ian still has a photograph of Burton in his house. In his words, “a big one”.

He says he thinks about him weekly.

Among the living, nearly forty years later.

🤘 Horns up 🤘

Shane O’Neill
Editor-in-Chief
The Chug Media